May 30, 2009
-
Jon,
Kate and their eight have attracted a huge TV audience, screaming
tabloid headlines and, now, a state labor investigation. In
a possible wake-up call to reality TV, the Pennsylvania Department
of Labor says it's looking into whether the hit show 'Jon
& Kate Plus 8' is complying with the state's child labor
law. TLC said Friday it "fully complies" with state
laws and regulations.
The TLC series follows Jon and Kate Gosselin as they raise
their eight young children, including 8-year-old twins and
sextuplets who just turned 5. The couple make $50,000-$75,000
an episode.
The Labor Department received a complaint
against the show and is "gathering information"
from its representatives, department spokesman Justin Fleming
told The Associated Press. Fleming would not say when the
complaint was filed or who filed it. The fact a complaint
is being investigated doesn't necessarily mean the department
believes the show did anything wrong.
Child actors and other young performers are protected by Pennsylvania
labor law, but it's not clear whether the law applies to reality
TV. Investigators will have to decide whether the Gosselins'
house in southeastern Pennsylvania is essentially a TV set
where producers direct much of the action -- in which case
the law may apply -- or a home where the kids aren't really
working but are simply living their lives, albeit in front
of the cameras.
Kate's brother and sister-in-law made waves this week by saying
the Gosselins are exploiting their children for financial
gain. Jon and Kate Gosselin are reportedly paid tens of thousands
of dollars per episode.
"Unfortunately, I think it has come
down to all about the ratings," sister-in-law Jodi Kreider
told CBS' 'The Early Show.' "And no one is looking at
these children as what they are going through and the life
consequences they are going to have as they get older."
Kreider said the children have told her they don't like the
cameras.
Her husband and Kate's brother, Kevin Kreider, said in the
same interview: "You can't imagine as a child realizing
that my birthday party, that all the outings that my parents
took me on were ... for ratings, and all organized by production
companies."
TLC spokeswoman Laurie Goldberg said in a statement Friday
that the network "fully complies with all applicable
laws and regulations" for all of its shows.
"For an extended period of time, we have been engaged
in cooperative discussions and supplied all requested information
to the Pennsylvania Department of Labor," Goldberg said.
State law permits kids who are at least 7 to work in the entertainment
industry, as long as a permit is obtained and certain rules
are followed. The law also allows performers younger than
7 to have "temporary employment ... in the production
of a motion picture."
"The fundamental question I see here is whether or not
they're employees, whether they're working, and whether the
Pennsylvania child labor law provisions would even apply to
this situation," he said.